| Year | League Trophy | Andi'Cap Trophy | ||
| 1959 | Les Bradbury | Peter Juneman | ||
| 1960 | Andy Wilson | Derek Wilmot | ||
| 1961 | Roger Heath | Derek Wilmot | ||
| 1962 | Les Bradbury | Derek Wilmot | ||
| 1963 | Les Bradbury | Joan Wilson | ||
| 1964 | John Cooper | Peter Juneman | ||
| 1965 | Les Bradbury | Unknown | ||
| 1966 | John Cooper | Unknown | ||
| 1967 | John Cooper | Roger & Lin Heath | ||
| 1968 | Roger Heath | Les Bradbury | ||
| 1969 | Roger & Lin Heath | Reta Bradbury | ||
| 1970 | Roger Heath | Reta Bradbury & Joan Wilson | ||
| 1971 | Roger Heath | Les Bradbury | ||
| 1972 | John Cooper | Mike Forsey & Valerie Jenkins | ||
| 1973 | Frank Roberts | Unknown | ||
| 1974 | Andy & Joan Wilson | Roger Heath | ||
| 1975 | Roger Heath & Gillian Greagsbey | The Wilkies | ||
| 1976 | Neville & Sheila Wilkie | Gillian Greagsbey | ||
| 1977 | Roger Heath & Gillian Greagsbey | Roger & Jenny Abbott | ||
| 1978 | Frank Roberts | Mike & Valerie Forsey | ||
| 1979 | Frank Roberts | Andy & Joan Wilson | ||
| 1980 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Brian Hennessy | ||
| 1981 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Bill & Janet Clack | ||
| 1982 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Robert & Sue Whale | ||
| 1983 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Joan Wilson | ||
| 1984 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Mike Patch | ||
| 1985 | Martin Gardner | Mike Patch | ||
| 1986 | Joan Powell | Win Harper & Nigel Ley | ||
| 1987 | Roger Heath | Rosy Treasure & Dave Saunders | ||
| 1988 | Andy Hooper, Geoff Hunt & Alan Hayslep | Les Bradbury, Jim & Pam Wescombe | ||
| 1989 | Roger Heath | Derek & Sheila Harding | ||
| 1990 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Melanie Abbott | ||
| 1991 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Andy Hooper, Ken White & Joan Powell | ||
| 1992 | Roger Heath | Derek & Sheila Harding | ||
| 1993 | Roger Heath | Peter Jagger & Cheryl Woodhouse | ||
| 1994 | Andy Hooper & Geoff Hunt | Roger Abbott | ||
| 1995 | Roger Heath | Jim & Pam Wescombe | ||
| 1996 | Geoff Hunt | Andy & Joan Wilson | ||
| 1997 | Roger Heath | Les Bradbury | ||
| 1998 | Alan Reeves | Derek and Sheila Harding | ||
| 1999 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Joan Wilson | ||
| 2000 | Roger Abbott | Andy Wilson | ||
| 2001 | Roger Heath | Andy Wilson | ||
| 2002 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Derek Harding | ||
| 2003 | Geoff Hunt & Alan Reeves | James Biggs | ||
| 2004 | Geoff Hunt | Roger Abbott | ||
| 2005 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Penny Biggs | ||
| 2006 | Roger Heath & Joyce Heywood | Brenda Wooden | ||
League Trophy
In that first full year of treasure hunts (1958) there was no trophy awarded at the end of the season for the best overall performer. However, as we can see from the minutes of an EYPC committee meeting held on 8th May 1959, things were about to change:
Treasure Hunt Rules - Time. It was decided to allow an overall time of 8 hours for the completion of Treasure Hunts. One point will be deducted for every 5 minutes taken in excess of this period.
It was decided to withdraw the £5 prize for winners of the league and substitute a trophy, this to be held for one year together with a replica. This replica together with another for runner may be held permanently.
At the end of the 1959 season the late Les Bradbury, who was chairman of our club between 1974 and 1986, became the first winner of the treasure hunters' league trophy.
Andi Cap Treasure Chest
The trophy is a treasure chest awarded once a year, usually at the first walk, based upon individual handicap calculated from the results of the previous season. Miraculously the treasure chest has survived the last 48 years and of course has its own tales to tell, see Notes from the Archives for the full story.